One of this week’s stories takes us into one of the most unusually imaginative space battles ever and even sneakily connects to the other two, which are related stories that ask what it would be like if women really were from “Venus” and how a man could get a perfect woman. I’m going to discuss those together because they make a nice pair.
James Gunn (1923-07-12)
“The Misogynist” (Galaxy, November 1952)
Robert Sheckley (1928-07-16/2005-12-09)
“The Perfect Woman” (Amazing, December 1953-January 1954)
In “The Misogynist,” a naive narrator introduces us to Harry, the “wit” who can tell jokes like no one else. He then repeats a story of Harry’s which conveys his ideas about women and which the narrator thinks tops all his previous jokes.
In “The Perfect Woman,” the year 3000 has arrived. Through the viewpoint of a hungover Mr. Morchek, we learn about the conversation he had the night before with a man who has married a Primitive Woman and learn what a Modern Woman is like as we observe Morchek’s relationship with his own wife.
There are nice twists in both these tales. The naive narrator is utilized well to get to the one in “The Misogynist” while the reader’s initial naivete about the society of the year 3000 is utilized well to get to the one in “The Perfect Woman.” Both are very economical (though “The Misogynist” could have been tightened still more). And they both have several interesting angles. Both would probably be taken as literally misogynistic today and that’s a reasonable interpretation from the internal realities of the stories. However, they can also be taken in the reverse sense, as mocking some men’s desires, expectations, or worldviews. It’s also interesting that, even if interpreted simplistically, it would only serve to show that all sorts of sensibilities could be represented in the “conformist” 1950s while today’s “diversity” has narrowed the conceptual possibilities of the genre. In a way, this would (aptly if taken seriously, and ironically if taken ironically) prove some of the Misogynist’s theorizing correct. But, heavy topical stuff aside, these are well-written and entertaining short stories.
Cordwainer Smith (1913-07-11/1966-08-06)
“The Game of Rat and Dragon” (Galaxy, October 1955)
In the far future of the Instrumentality of Mankind, people have progressed to the point of traveling through space via planoforming, but have encountered malevolent underspace beings who would make this impossible, if not for the telepathic battle teams of human and cat who perceive the enemy as dragons or rats, respectively, and, together, are capable of fighting and usually destroying the beings with light bombs. We learn of this amazing milieu and witness one such battle, as well as the effects of one mind upon another.
It’s hard to grasp that the first section or two-fifths of this story is essentially just an infodump because it’s so bizarre, fascinating, and enlivened with points of emotional connection. Then it moves step-by-step into the assignment of “partners,” the preparations, the combat, and the aftermath, showing excellent structure and control. But the greatest power of this story is its uninhibited imagination.
4 thoughts on “Birthday Reviews: Gunn, Sheckley, Smith”
In the beginning years of my site I was a huge fan of Gunn.
Have you read THE JOY MAKERS, THE IMMORTALS, or even STATION IN SPACE? If there is ever a book that coincidentally guessed a future healthcare system similar to the one currently plaguing the US, it’s THE IMMORTALS.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Nope, I haven’t gotten to Gunn in depth yet, but I do have The Joy Makers and some others reasonably high in the Pile so maybe some day not too far away.
All the ones I listed are reviewed on my site 🙂
Pingback: Birthday Reviews: Complete Linked Index to Authors and Stories | Featured Futures